- Number of Discs: 2
- Released: September 7, 2004
- Label: Victory Records
- 1.Smashed to Pieces
- 2.Red Light Pledge
- 3.Giving Up
- 5.Last Days of Summer
- 6.Bleeds No More
- 7.Hear Me Out
- 8.The Weak and the Wounded
- 9.Wish I Could Forget You
- 10.When Broken Is Easily Fixed
- 11.Friends in Fall River - (bonus track)
- 12.Forever and a Day - (bonus track)
Silverstein: Shane Told (vocals); Neil Boshart, Josh Bradford (guitar); Billy Hamilton (bass); Paul Koehler (drums).
Contains 2 bonus tracks.
Silverstein (Band): Billy Hamilton (bass guitar); Paul Koehler (drums); Shane Told, Neil Boshart, Josh Bradford.
Personnel: Shane Told (vocals, guitar); Kyle Bishop (vocals); Richard McWalter, Neil Boshart, Josh Bradford (guitar).
Audio Mixer: Justin Koop.
Liner Note Author: Shane Told.
Recording information: Mount Fairview (01/2003-02/2003); Unity Gain (01/2003-02/2003).
Silverstein's Victory debut is a jarring mixture of emo's earnest determination, elements of hardcore, and the heaviest of heavy metal. While vocalist Shane Told delivers lines like "How can I say I love you back, you never made me happy" in a cracked, soaring singing voice, When Broken Is Easily Fixed actually begins with a ragged scream that's as arresting as his singing is plaintive. Musically, the LP is dominated by the dynamic shifts and driving melodies of emo. But Silverstein's membership was derived from existing hardcore, metal, and punk squads, and these influences are never very far from view. "Last Days of Summer" begins as a June day ends, with shuffling percussion and gently strummed guitars. But just as the fragile strains of a violin drift in, Told's growling, scarred alter ego appears behind his singing self. The song's structure breaks apart, and re-forms as a churning post-hardcore anthem driven by his scarred, screaming id. The track gives way to the scathing hardcore of "Bleeds No More," but even its furious rhythms aren't safe from Silverstein's experimental touch -- its bridge features an atmospheric interlude complete with programming and additional violin. Things get even more bipolar with "The Weak and the Wounded," on which Told's two sides duet before the track bursts through the storm clouds into a gliding chorus. But all is not well. "Love in my eyes, lust in my heart," Told sings, only to sneer finally "I made it all up. Lies, deceit empowers me." When Broken Is Easily Fixed is a rousing, cathartic record that effectively blurs the lines between emo, hardcore, and metal. It drags the listener behind the car on an emotional roller coaster that teeters on rotting wood. For your own safety, keep your hands and arms away from the stereo at all times. ~ Johnny Loftus