Rolling Stone - 12/25/03, p.110
Included in Rolling Stone's "50 Best Albums of 2003"
Rolling Stone - 10/30/03, p.864 stars out of 5
- "...[One] of the best things about ROOM ON FIRE is that...the Strokes have resisted the temptation to hit the brakes, grow up and screw around with a sound that doesn't need fixing....This record was built for thrills and speed."
Spin - 12/03, pp.121-2
"...The gambit pays off: ROOM ON FIRE is the rare album you could imagine rocking college radio and storming Clear Channel's barricades..." - Grade: A-
Entertainment Weekly - 10/31/03, pp.71-72
"...There's still something undeniably appealing about the Strokes. They're raw and corrosive, yet surprisingly intimate..." - Rating: B
Q - 01/01/04, p.83Ranked #7
in Q's "The 50 Best Albums of 2003"
Q - 11/03, p.1025 stars out of 5
- "...Everything a second album needs to be, it's like IS THIS IT but more emotional, more colourful, slightly better..."
Uncut - 01/04, pp.84-7Ranked #45
in Uncut's "Albums Of The Year 2003"
Uncut - 11/03, p.1084 stars out of 5
- "...Once again 11 concise, usually thrilling songs filled with bewilderment, romance and a sense of climactic payback..."
CMJ - 11/17/03, p.8
"...[Repaints] its predecessor as a promising first release, with potential to grow into something truly formidable....[the opening track] is arguably the Strokes' finest moment to date..."
Mojo (Publisher) - 01/01/04, p.60Ranked #4
in Mojo's "The Best of 2003"
Mojo (Publisher) - 11/03, p.1244 stars out of 5
- "...This record is good. Thirty-three minutes and 13 seconds of bruised pop music. Tough, intense, no slack..."
The Strokes: Julian Casablancas (vocals); Nick Valensi, Albert Hammond, Jr. (guitar); Nikolai Fraiture (bass); Fab Moretti (drums).
Recorded at TMF Studios, New York, New York.
Personnel: Julian Casablancas (vocals); Nick Valensi, Albert Hammond, Jr. (guitar); Fabrizio Moretti (drums).
Recording information: TMF Studios, New York, NY.
Photographer: Colin Lane.
Unknown Contributor Role: J.P. Bowersock.
Arranger: The Strokes.
After the hype--and subsequent backlash--over the Strokes' debut album, IS THIS IT, many fans and skeptics alike came to realize that the band's catchy, punk-pillaging rock ditties were, ultimately, very difficult to resist. Their eagerly anticipated follow-up, ROOM ON FIRE, is cut from the same vintage 1970s cloth, but added flourishes keep the album from sounding like a mere redux.
"What Ever Happened?" opens ROOM ON FIRE with a chiming, staccato guitar riff and kicks into the immediately identifiable Strokes swagger. However, while listening to Julian Casablancas's melancholy lyrics and the song's carefully crafted changes, it's clear that this is a maturing band that knows its strengths. This notion is further supported by the hard-charging "Reptilia," one of the group's finest tunes to date. And though the Strokes opted out of working with Radiohead producer Nigel Godrich, the concept of expanding their palette (even if only slightly) stuck, given the presence of keyboard sounds (on the gleefully Cars-like "12:51" and "The End Has No End") and reggae-influenced guitars (on "Automatic Stop" and "Between Love & Hate"). Although ROOM ON FIRE doesn't mark a radical musical departure for the band, the concise and consistently engaging album solidifies their status as skilled rock revivalists.